Augustyniak Insurance

The story of Augustyniak Insurance Group begins not in a boardroom, but on the football field. Founded in 2005 by Mike Augustyniak, a former fullback for the New York Jets, the agency was born from a desire to bring the same level of dedication and teamwork found in professional sports to the insurance industry. After transitioning from his NFL career, Mike saw a gap in the market for a truly independent agency that prioritized the client's needs over the interests of a single insurance carrier.

Starting in Jacksonville, Florida, the agency has grown from a small local operation into a trusted name across the state. By choosing to remain independent, Augustyniak Insurance Group unlocked the ability to shop multiple carriers—over 32 of them, including major names like Nationwide, Progressive, and AAA—to find the perfect fit for each client. Today, the agency serves over 5,000 clients, offering a comprehensive suite of protection ranging from auto and home to business and life insurance. What started as a second career for a professional athlete has evolved into a pillar of the Jacksonville community, driven by a commitment to integrity, personalized service, and the belief that every client deserves a champion in their corner.