Upgrade to Himalayas Plus and turbocharge your job search.
Sign up now and join over 100,000 remote workers who receive personalized job alerts, curated job matches, and more for free!
For job seekers
Create your profileBrowse remote jobsDiscover remote companiesJob description keyword finderRemote work adviceCareer guidesJob application trackerAI resume builderResume examples and templatesAI cover letter generatorCover letter examplesAI headshot generatorAI interview prepInterview questions and answersAI interview answer generatorAI career coachFree resume builderResume summary generatorResume bullet points generatorResume skills section generatorRemote jobs RSSRemote jobs widgetCommunity rewardsJoin the remote work revolution
Himalayas is the best remote job board. Join over 200,000 job seekers finding remote jobs at top companies worldwide.
Upgrade to unlock Himalayas' premium features and turbocharge your job search.
Sign up now and join over 100,000 remote workers who receive personalized job alerts, curated job matches, and more for free!
Teaching Assistants are the backbone of effective classroom environments, providing crucial support that allows lead teachers to focus on core instruction while ensuring every student receives personalized attention.
This role offers a direct pathway to impact young lives, fostering a love for learning and contributing significantly to educational outcomes, making it a highly rewarding career for those passionate about student development.
$33,400 USD
(U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2023)
Range: $23,000 - $45,000+ USD (U.S. national average, varies by experience and location)
4%
as fast as average (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2022-2032)
A Teaching Assistant (TA), sometimes known as a Teacher's Aide or Paraeducator, provides crucial support to a lead teacher in a classroom setting. This role focuses on facilitating student learning and managing classroom operations, allowing the lead teacher to concentrate on core instruction. TAs work directly with students, offering individualized attention and reinforcing lessons, particularly for those who need extra help.
This position differs significantly from a full-fledged teacher, who is responsible for designing curriculum, leading instruction, and overall classroom management. While TAs assist with these areas, they do not hold primary instructional authority. It also differs from a tutor, who typically works with students one-on-one outside the regular classroom structure. The Teaching Assistant is an integral part of the classroom ecosystem, ensuring a smoother, more effective learning experience for all students.
The qualification landscape for a Teaching Assistant (TA) focuses heavily on practical experience, empathy, and foundational academic support skills. While formal education is often beneficial, direct experience in educational settings or with specific age groups frequently outweighs advanced degrees. Requirements vary significantly by the educational institution (e.g., primary, secondary, special education, higher education) and the specific subject matter.
For primary and secondary school TAs, a relevant qualification like a Level 2 or 3 Certificate in Supporting Teaching and Learning in Schools is highly valued, or even a Bachelor's degree in Education or a related field. Practical experience, such as volunteering in classrooms or working with children, is often a must-have. For TAs in higher education, requirements shift toward subject matter expertise, often necessitating enrollment in or completion of a graduate program related to the course being assisted.
Certifications in areas like first aid, safeguarding, or behavior management add significant value across all TA roles. The skill landscape for TAs is evolving to include more digital literacy and adaptability to online learning environments. The balance between breadth of general support skills and depth in specific subject areas depends entirely on the role's context. Misconceptions often include viewing the role as purely administrative; TAs play a crucial role in student engagement, differentiation, and direct learning support.
Becoming a Teaching Assistant (TA) offers various entry points, depending on your background and the educational level you wish to support. Many TAs start with a high school diploma and a strong desire to help students, while others might hold an associate's or bachelor's degree, especially if they aim for specialized roles or future teaching positions. The timeline for entry can range from a few weeks if you already meet basic qualifications to several months if you need to complete specific training or certifications.
Entry strategies vary significantly by region and school district. Some districts require specific paraprofessional certifications or college credits, while others prioritize practical experience working with children or a particular subject matter expertise. Smaller schools or those in rural areas might have more flexible requirements compared to large urban districts. Networking with local educators, attending school board meetings, and volunteering can uncover opportunities not widely advertised.
A common misconception is that a TA role is only for those aspiring to be teachers. Many individuals find fulfilling long-term careers as TAs, valuing the direct student interaction and support roles. While a portfolio isn't typically required, demonstrating a genuine passion for education, strong communication skills, and a patient demeanor is crucial for securing a position in this field.
The educational landscape for a Teaching Assistant (TA) varies significantly by the educational institution and the specific subject matter. Formal university degrees are often preferred, especially for TAs in higher education or specialized K-12 settings. A bachelor's degree in the subject area being taught is a common requirement, costing $40,000-$100,000+ over four years. Some roles, particularly in research-intensive universities, may even prefer candidates pursuing a master's or Ph.D. in their field, which can add another $20,000-$60,000 and two to five years.
Alternative pathways exist, especially for K-12 TAs. Many school districts accept candidates with an Associate's degree, costing $5,000-$15,000 over two years, or relevant certifications. Online courses and self-study modules focusing on classroom management, special education support, or instructional techniques can supplement these foundational degrees. These typically range from free resources to several hundred dollars for a certificate, requiring 6-18 months of flexible study. Employers generally value practical experience alongside theoretical knowledge; therefore, volunteering or internships in educational settings are highly beneficial, regardless of the chosen educational path.
Continuous learning is crucial for TAs. Professional development workshops, often provided by school districts or universities, focus on new teaching methodologies, technology integration, and student support strategies. These short courses usually cost under $500 and enhance a TA's effectiveness and career progression. The market perception favors candidates who demonstrate both foundational knowledge and practical skills in supporting diverse learners. The specific educational needs for a TA depend heavily on the age group, subject, and whether the role is in a public, private, or higher education setting.
Compensation for a Teaching Assistant (TA) varies significantly based on several factors, moving beyond just the base hourly wage or stipend. Geographic location plays a crucial role, as salaries in high cost-of-living areas, particularly major metropolitan centers or university towns, are often higher to account for living expenses. Conversely, rural or lower cost-of-living regions may offer less.
Experience and the specific institution dramatically influence earning potential. TAs at large research universities or specialized private schools often earn more than those at smaller community colleges or K-12 settings. Specialization in high-demand subjects, such as STEM fields or foreign languages, can also command higher compensation.
Total compensation packages for TAs often extend beyond direct pay. Many university-based TA roles include valuable benefits like tuition waivers or reductions, health insurance, and access to professional development resources. These non-cash benefits can significantly increase the overall value of the compensation, sometimes surpassing the monetary salary itself. Remote TA opportunities, while less common for direct classroom support, can impact salary ranges by allowing for geographic arbitrage, though most TA roles are still tied to a physical location. International market variations exist, and the figures provided here are specific to the United States Dollar (USD) context.
| Level | US Median | US Average |
|---|---|---|
| Teaching Assistant | $30k USD | $32k USD |
| Senior Teaching Assistant | $36k USD | $38k USD |
| Lead Teaching Assistant | $42k USD | $45k USD |
Career progression for a Teaching Assistant primarily involves deepening pedagogical skills, taking on more responsibility, and often specializing in subject areas or student support. This field offers both individual contributor (IC) tracks, where TAs become highly proficient in direct student support and curriculum delivery, and potential pathways into formal teaching or administrative roles. Advancement speed depends on performance, the educational institution's structure, and the specific academic level or subject area.
Advancement often involves demonstrating a strong grasp of instructional methods, effective classroom management, and the ability to work autonomously with students. Lateral moves might include shifting to different age groups (e.g., elementary to high school) or specific learning support roles. Larger institutions may offer more structured progression, while smaller schools might see TAs taking on broader, more varied responsibilities.
Networking within the educational community, seeking mentorship from experienced teachers, and pursuing further education or certifications in pedagogy or specific subjects significantly impact career trajectory. Common milestones include leading small group instruction, developing supplementary materials, or taking on mentorship roles for new TAs. Some TAs pivot into full-time teaching, curriculum development, or educational administration.
Ace your application with our purpose-built resources:
Proven layouts and keywords hiring managers scan for.
View examplesTeaching Assistant roles translate globally, supporting lead educators in diverse learning environments. Demand for TAs remains stable across countries, driven by educational reforms and increased student-teacher ratios. Cultural approaches to education and regulatory frameworks for support staff vary significantly. Professionals consider international TA opportunities for cultural immersion, language acquisition, and gaining diverse pedagogical experience. While no universal certifications exist, a TEFL or TESOL certificate can aid English-speaking TA roles abroad.
Teaching Assistant salaries vary widely based on country, institution type, and whether the role is in K-12 or higher education. In North America, a K-12 TA in the USA earns approximately $25,000-$35,000 USD annually, while in Canada, it's about $20,000-$30,000 CAD ($15,000-$22,000 USD). University TAs may earn more, often with tuition benefits.
European salaries differ considerably. In the UK, a TA typically earns £18,000-£24,000 GBP ($23,000-$30,000 USD). Germany offers around €20,000-€28,000 EUR ($22,000-$30,000 USD) for school TAs. These figures often reflect lower cost of living outside major cities compared to North America.
Asia-Pacific regions present varied compensation. In Australia, TAs might earn $40,000-$50,000 AUD ($26,000-$33,000 USD). However, in parts of Southeast Asia, such as Vietnam or Thailand, local TA salaries are much lower, often $5,000-$10,000 USD, but purchasing power is significantly higher. Middle Eastern countries, particularly the UAE, can offer tax-free salaries from $25,000-$40,000 USD, often including housing allowances, which greatly enhances take-home pay.
Latin American TA roles typically pay $8,000-$15,000 USD, but the cost of living in countries like Mexico or Colombia is considerably lower. Benefits packages also differ; North America and Europe often include health insurance and pension contributions, while other regions might offer housing, flights, or fewer non-salary benefits. International experience or specific language skills can sometimes command slightly higher pay, especially in private or international schools.
Understanding the current market for Teaching Assistants is crucial for setting realistic career expectations. The educational landscape has evolved significantly since 2023, shaped by post-pandemic recovery efforts and ongoing shifts in student needs.
Broader economic factors, such as local government funding and school district budgets, directly influence TA hiring. Market realities for TAs vary considerably by geographic region, school district size, and the specific needs of the student population. This analysis provides an honest assessment of current conditions.
Teaching Assistants face significant competition, especially for entry-level roles, as many seek to gain classroom experience. Budget constraints in educational institutions often limit the number of available positions. Furthermore, the role can be overlooked in resource allocation discussions, leading to fewer full-time opportunities.
Economic uncertainties sometimes reduce school funding, impacting support staff hiring. This leads to longer job search timelines for many candidates.
Despite challenges, strong demand persists for Teaching Assistants in special education and early childhood education. Schools actively seek TAs who can provide one-on-one support for students with diverse learning requirements. Bilingual TAs are also highly sought after, particularly in diverse urban districts.
Emerging opportunities exist in roles supporting hybrid learning environments or providing specialized intervention for literacy and numeracy. Professionals can position themselves advantageously by acquiring certifications in special education support or behavior management. Volunteering in schools or community programs also provides valuable experience.
Underserved markets, such as districts with high student-to-teacher ratios or significant populations of English language learners, often have more consistent openings. Gaining proficiency in educational software and data tracking tools offers a competitive edge. This allows TAs to support teachers more effectively.
The role of a Teaching Assistant is evolving significantly, driven by rapid advancements in educational technology and shifting pedagogical approaches. Understanding these emerging trends is crucial for professionals seeking to advance their careers and secure future-proof roles. New specialization opportunities are continually created by the integration of artificial intelligence in learning, the expansion of inclusive education practices, and the increasing demand for personalized student support.
Positioning oneself early in these emerging areas offers a substantial advantage. Professionals who develop expertise in cutting-edge specializations often command premium compensation and experience accelerated career growth, as their skills are in high demand and short supply. While established specializations remain valuable, focusing on emerging areas allows Teaching Assistants to become pioneers, shaping the future of education rather than merely adapting to it.
Many emerging areas, while nascent, are quickly gaining traction and are expected to become mainstream within the next three to five years, creating a significant number of job opportunities. Investing in these specializations now offers a strong risk-reward profile; the initial effort to acquire new skills pays off with enhanced career prospects and greater impact on student outcomes. This strategic foresight ensures Teaching Assistants remain relevant and influential in an educational landscape that is continuously transforming.
Making informed career decisions requires a clear understanding of both the benefits and challenges associated with a particular profession. Career experiences, including those of a Teaching Assistant, can vary significantly depending on the specific school, student population, and individual responsibilities assigned. What one person perceives as a major advantage, another might see as a challenge, based on their personal values, skills, and lifestyle preferences. Furthermore, the nature of the role and its associated pros and cons may evolve at different stages of a career, from early entry to more experienced levels. This assessment aims to provide a realistic, balanced view of the Teaching Assistant role to help set appropriate expectations and support thoughtful career planning.
Becoming a Teaching Assistant typically requires a high school diploma or equivalent, though some roles may prefer or require an Associate's degree or specific certifications in education or childcare. For higher education TA roles, enrollment in a relevant degree program is often a prerequisite. Experience working with children or in an educational setting, even as a volunteer, is highly valued and often expected.
The time it takes to become a Teaching Assistant can vary. If you meet the basic educational requirements, you could potentially secure an entry-level position within a few weeks to months, especially with relevant experience. If you need to complete a certification or an Associate's degree, this could take 1-2 years. Networking and applying for positions during your study period can help shorten the transition time.
Explore similar roles that might align with your interests and skills:
A growing field with similar skill requirements and career progression opportunities.
Explore career guideA growing field with similar skill requirements and career progression opportunities.
Explore career guideA growing field with similar skill requirements and career progression opportunities.
Explore career guideA growing field with similar skill requirements and career progression opportunities.
Explore career guide≈112,000
openings annually (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2022-2032)
High school diploma or equivalent; some positions may require an Associate's degree or completion of a specific number of college credits, or passing a state/local assessment.
Teaching Assistants typically work in a classroom setting within a school, ranging from elementary to high school levels. The environment is dynamic and often fast-paced, requiring constant interaction with students and the lead teacher. Collaboration is central, as TAs work closely with the main teacher to support learning objectives and manage the class. The schedule generally aligns with school hours, which means early mornings and afternoons, with occasional after-school duties for events or meetings. While most work is on-site, some may assist with virtual learning environments. The role demands patience, adaptability, and the ability to manage multiple tasks while maintaining a supportive and engaging atmosphere for students.
Teaching Assistants primarily use traditional classroom tools and materials, such as whiteboards, projectors, textbooks, and art supplies. They often assist students with educational software and online learning platforms like Google Classroom or Canvas, navigating digital assignments and resources. Communication tools, including email and school-specific messaging systems, are essential for interacting with the lead teacher and sometimes with parents. They also use basic office software like Microsoft Word or Google Docs for preparing materials and recording information. Depending on the school, they might utilize student information systems for attendance or basic record-keeping, though this is typically more managed by the lead teacher.
The job market for Teaching Assistants shows steady demand, primarily driven by student enrollment trends and educational funding. In higher education, the need for TAs correlates directly with class sizes and the complexity of courses, especially in large lecture settings or subjects requiring significant lab or discussion sections. The K-12 sector sees consistent demand for TAs to support diverse learning needs, including special education, early childhood, and general classroom assistance.
Technological advancements, particularly in learning management systems and online education tools, are influencing the role. While some administrative tasks might become more efficient, the core need for human interaction, direct student support, and grading remains strong. AI tools could assist TAs with content creation or initial feedback, but they are unlikely to replace the nuanced support TAs provide.
The outlook suggests stable growth, with projections for educational support services generally aligning with overall employment growth. Specific growth hotspots include urban and suburban areas experiencing population increases, leading to higher student enrollments. Demand for TAs supporting students with special needs or English language learners is also projected to rise. The profession is generally recession-resistant as education remains a fundamental service, though funding levels can fluctuate. Future-proofing involves developing strong communication skills, adaptability to new educational technologies, and a deep understanding of subject matter to provide valuable, personalized student support.
Supports the lead teacher in daily classroom operations, including preparing materials, supervising students, and assisting with individual or small-group learning activities. Works under direct supervision, focusing on executing assigned tasks and maintaining an orderly learning environment. Direct impact on student engagement and participation within structured activities.
Developing foundational classroom support skills like assisting with materials, managing student behavior, and reinforcing teacher instructions. Learning to provide individualized or small-group help. Building strong communication with lead teachers and understanding classroom routines are key priorities. Familiarity with basic educational technology and school policies is also crucial.
Assumes greater responsibility for specific instructional segments, such as leading small group lessons, tutoring students, or managing classroom transitions. Provides direct input on student progress and behavioral observations. Operates with more autonomy, often managing specific classroom areas or student groups independently while collaborating closely with the lead teacher.
Refining instructional techniques for diverse learners and developing proactive classroom management strategies. Taking initiative in identifying student needs and proposing support solutions. Focusing on curriculum integration and contributing to lesson planning. Mentoring newer TAs and participating in professional development related to specific subjects or educational methodologies are important.
Oversees and coordinates the activities of other Teaching Assistants, often across multiple classrooms or grade levels. Takes a lead role in curriculum support, developing supplementary educational materials, and implementing behavior management plans. Provides mentorship and training to junior TAs. Plays a significant role in improving overall instructional effectiveness and student outcomes.
Mastering advanced instructional design principles and developing comprehensive classroom leadership skills. Leading professional development for other TAs and contributing to school-wide educational initiatives. Focusing on curriculum adaptation, assessment support, and fostering a collaborative learning environment across multiple classrooms or subjects. Pursuing advanced certifications in education or specialized support areas.
Personalizable templates that showcase your impact.
View examplesPractice with the questions asked most often.
View examplesReady-to-use JD for recruiters and hiring teams.
View examplesRemote work opportunities for Teaching Assistants are limited but growing, primarily in online education or specialized virtual support roles. These roles typically involve assisting online instructors, moderating discussions, or grading assignments for virtual students. Legal and tax implications for international remote work can be complex, requiring understanding of tax residency and employer obligations in different jurisdictions.
Time zone differences present a significant challenge for international collaboration, often necessitating flexible work hours. Digital nomad visas are generally not suitable for typical TA roles, as most require a direct employer or specific educational institution affiliation. Some online learning platforms or universities hire TAs globally, but these are often part-time or contract-based, impacting salary expectations.
Geographic arbitrage is possible, where a TA earns a higher salary from a developed country while living in a lower cost-of-living area. Practical considerations include reliable high-speed internet, a dedicated workspace, and effective communication tools. Companies like Coursera, edX, or large online universities occasionally post international remote TA positions.
Teaching Assistant roles abroad typically fall under skilled worker or specialized occupation visa categories. Popular destinations include the UK (Skilled Worker visa), Canada (Temporary Foreign Worker Program, requiring an LMIA), and Australia (Temporary Skill Shortage visa). Requirements often include a relevant educational background, sometimes a bachelor's degree, and proof of English language proficiency for non-native speakers.
Credential recognition is crucial; academic qualifications may need evaluation by bodies like WES or UK ENIC. Some countries might require a criminal background check. The typical visa timeline ranges from 2 to 6 months, depending on the country and application volume. Permanent residency pathways are less direct for TA roles alone, often requiring several years of continuous skilled employment.
For university-level TA positions, especially for graduate students, specific student or academic visas may apply, often linked to a scholarship or stipend. Language requirements, particularly for non-English speaking countries, are critical for classroom interaction. Family visas for dependents are generally available if the primary visa holder meets specific income thresholds. Some countries might offer streamlined processes for in-demand educational support roles, but this is less common for entry-level TA positions.
The demand for Teaching Assistants (TAs) shows regional variations; urban and suburban districts often have more openings than rural areas. Many districts prioritize TAs with specialized skills, such as supporting students with special educational needs or English language learners. The role often requires a blend of academic support and behavioral management.
Hiring patterns for TAs frequently align with the academic calendar, with peak recruitment occurring in late spring and summer for the upcoming school year. Post-pandemic, schools seek TAs who can help address learning gaps and provide individualized attention. While AI tools assist teachers, they have not significantly displaced TA roles, as the human element of direct student support remains crucial.
Salary trends for TAs are generally stable but often reflect local cost of living and school district budgets. Many positions are part-time or hourly, impacting overall compensation. Experienced TAs with specialized certifications or a strong track record of student progress often command better terms.
School districts increasingly look for TAs who are adaptable and proficient with basic educational technology platforms. This includes tools for virtual learning and student progress tracking. The normalization of remote learning during the pandemic highlighted the need for TAs capable of supporting both in-person and hybrid classroom models.
This specialization focuses on supporting students and educators in environments that leverage AI-powered learning platforms and tools. Teaching Assistants in this role help integrate adaptive learning software, assist with data interpretation from AI assessments, and guide students through personalized learning paths generated by algorithms. Their expertise ensures the effective and ethical use of AI to enhance student engagement and academic performance.
This area involves providing specialized assistance to students with diverse learning needs, including those with neurodevelopmental differences, physical disabilities, or emotional challenges, within mainstream or specialized educational settings. Teaching Assistants specializing here implement individualized education programs (IEPs), adapt learning materials, and employ assistive technologies to ensure equitable access to education. Their work is vital for creating inclusive and supportive learning environments.
This specialization focuses on supporting students' emotional and social development alongside their academic progress. Teaching Assistants in this role help identify students who may be struggling with anxiety, stress, or peer issues, facilitating positive social interactions and teaching coping mechanisms. They often work closely with school counselors and parents to create a nurturing and supportive learning environment that promotes overall well-being.
This specialization involves assisting with the design, implementation, and evaluation of virtual and hybrid learning environments. Teaching Assistants in this role manage online classroom platforms, troubleshoot technical issues for students and teachers, facilitate virtual group activities, and ensure student engagement in remote settings. Their expertise is critical for effective and accessible digital education delivery.
This emerging area involves supporting students in developing critical digital literacy skills, including responsible online behavior, media evaluation, and computational thinking. Teaching Assistants in this role help integrate digital citizenship lessons, guide students in safe internet use, and facilitate projects that develop problem-solving abilities using digital tools. They prepare students for a technologically advanced future by fostering essential 21st-century skills.
Salaries for Teaching Assistants vary significantly based on location, type of institution (public school, private school, university), and experience. Entry-level TAs might earn between $20,000 to $30,000 annually, while experienced TAs, especially those in specialized roles or higher education, could earn $35,000 to $45,000 or more. Benefits packages also differ, with public school systems often offering comprehensive benefits.
Teaching Assistant roles often align with school hours, providing a predictable schedule that can be appealing for work-life balance. However, the role can be demanding, requiring patience, adaptability, and the ability to manage multiple tasks simultaneously. Some TAs may work extended hours for events, parent-teacher conferences, or to prepare materials, but generally, the schedule allows for personal time outside of school hours.
The job market for Teaching Assistants is generally stable, with consistent demand driven by class sizes and the need for individualized student support. Job security can depend on school funding and student enrollment numbers, but the fundamental need for classroom assistance ensures ongoing opportunities. Special education TA roles often have particularly strong demand.
Teaching Assistants have several avenues for career growth. Many use the role as a stepping stone to becoming a certified teacher by pursuing a Bachelor's or Master's degree in education. Others specialize in areas like special education, behavioral support, or instructional technology. With experience, TAs can also take on lead assistant roles, mentor new TAs, or move into administrative support positions within schools.
A primary challenge for Teaching Assistants is managing diverse student needs and behaviors while supporting the lead teacher's instruction. This requires strong communication skills, patience, and the ability to adapt quickly to unexpected situations. Another challenge can be the emotional labor involved in supporting students through academic and personal struggles. TAs must also navigate classroom dynamics and maintain professional boundaries.
While most Teaching Assistant positions require a physical presence in the classroom to directly support students and the teacher, some limited remote or hybrid opportunities might exist for specific tasks like grading, preparing digital materials, or providing online tutoring. However, the core of the TA role, which involves direct student interaction and classroom management, is inherently in-person. Fully remote TA roles are rare.
A growing field with similar skill requirements and career progression opportunities.
Explore career guideUnderstanding where you stand today is the first step toward your career goals. Our Career Coach helps identify skill gaps and create personalized plans.
Get a detailed assessment of your current skills versus Teaching Assistant requirements. Our AI Career Coach identifies specific areas for improvement with personalized recommendations.
See your skills gapEvaluate your overall readiness for Teaching Assistant roles with our AI Career Coach. Receive personalized recommendations for education, projects, and experience to boost your competitiveness.
Assess your readinessLearn from experienced Teaching Assistants who are actively working in the field. See their roles, skills, and insights.
Motivated assistant teacher delivering activity-based, disciplined learning for Nursery–Upper Primary.
Dedicated Teaching Assistant with experience in supporting classroom activities.
Aspiring Intermediate Phase teacher focused on student growth and classroom support.
Dedicated Higher Level Teaching Assistant focused on pupil wellbeing and organised operations.
Ready to take the next step? Browse the latest Teaching Assistant opportunities from top companies.
Singapore onlyEmployee count: 501-1000
Canada onlyEmployee count: 5000+
Salary: 44k-69k USD
United States only
Germany only